The music industry thrives top top two straightforward principles. Love exists, and also love is broken. Numerous pop artists have actually exploited the fleeting nature the their personal relationships, writing cloying love songs today and fiery breakup anthems tomorrow. What we rarely hear around in pop music are songs about the loneliness that comes in a people where love never lasts.

You are watching: All of me wants all of you lyrics

What Sufjan and also Carrie necessary was not perfect love or idealistic love, yet a love in the midst of brokenness.On his latest record Carrie and also Lowell, Sufjan Stevens’s pains earnest ”All of Me Wants all of You” is the sound of a man fatigued by damaged love. Stevens’s partnership with his mother was like a hookup/breakup bike on repeat, seeing her for a couple of intense work or weeks at a time just to lose her again for months and also years. He wonders whether his mother’s terminal cancer is a blessing or a curse, quietly wavering, “Shall we beat it or memory it?” it’s the same question he asked as a son every time his mommy abandoned the again. By she bedside in the waning moments of her life, that sings, “On the sheet I view your horizon.” also as that hugs her, “I’m just a ghost you walk best through.” fatality slowly wrests the mother he wanted to love indigenous his understand one last time. Miscellaneous in his heart won’t let the let go. Stevens understands that his turmoil is not unique yet universal: every love is broken, and also yet our souls long for various other souls.

Confusion about the nature that “All the Me Wants every one of You” has occurred surrounding a mysterious allusion in the first verse: “Manelich, ns feel so used.” Some have actually posited this is a moniker because that a remote male lover. This obscure recommendation is a an essential element in understanding exactly how Stevens sees his connection with his mommy Carrie. Many importantly, Stevens look at himself as Manelich, a guy who must choose to love in the midst of disastrous brokenness or provide up altogether.

Stevens’s Manelich is discovered in the Catalan pat Terra Baixa (Marta that the Lowlands) written by Àngel Guimerà in 1896. That is a goat shepherd, an innocent guy who has actually spends many of his life populated on the mountainside. His contented peace is disrupted through Sebastian, his master, who proposes the he descend from the mountain right into the lowlands to become the miller by marrying the peasant girl Marta. V rapture, Manelich bursts right into the town in a scene reminiscent of friend the Elf’s “I’m in love, ns in love, and also I don’t care who to know it!”

Manelich’s first experience v love is complimentary and innocent. He assumes love will certainly be pure, his bride Marta will be spotless and beautiful, and his marriage will stay unpolluted. As Manelich provides his jubilant entrance, the servants mock that behind his earlier for his naïveté. A few pity him, sighing, “Poor Manelich!” The exuberant goat-keeper does no realize that is a goat gift prodded along by the menacing staff of Sebastian. He is as well enthralled with love to an alert the stifled chortles and also the red faces around him.

In plot I, Manelich represents the childlike innocence of an initial love. Sufjan Stevens’s childhood years to be in plenty of ways choose Manelich’s beforehand experience. We’ve seen the story countless times. The is the boy who waits because that the return of an absentee parent like an eager puppy. The is the son too chaste to establish the mother he loves is no the shining statuette he idolizes. It is the kid who has not come that age; his love is still idealistic, blind, and impossible.

In the second act, Manelich concerns the slow realization that love is various from what he had thought. Marta continues to be cold and unfeeling toward him, and also she refuses to welcome him to their marital bed. That spends his nights sitting outside her door wondering what has gone wrong. The downhearted townspeople watch as the shepherd through childlike innocence i do not care a man crushed by the world. Everyone other than Manelich knew the his marriage was a sham. Sebastian had actually arranged the union to cover up his own predatory partnership with tender Marta. Manelich had been lured away from his blissful life tending his lovely goats to become a device in the hand that his devilish master.

As Manelich learns much more and much more of the truth, the villagers start to pity him. Your haughty laughter transforms to quiet tears. The joke is in reality on them. Manelich’s painful suffer reminds them everywhere again that love is never simple, plain, and joyful. In a damaged world, love, too, is broken. Stevens sees himself as the Manelich of the world. His childlike love because that his mother was foolish. Carrie pushed that away and remained distantly absent—a mere rundown of a shadow. She is Marta of the Lowlands—a woman broken by the world. His mother was a victim of her circumstances and also her very own vices, abused by the world. The is feasible that, like Marta, she shielded it s her from the innocent love of another because the reminded her of the innocence that was stolen from her.

Once Manelich realizes the his marital relationship is a farce, the ponders his following move. Perhaps he need to celebrate the end of his foolish idealism and retreat come the mountains with his goats. Probably he have to remain come fight for his lover Marta, regardless of the challenges. Stevens battles with this same predicament: “Shall us beat this or memory it?” Is love ever worthwhile in a human being where everyone is broken and also love is never ever the rosy point that it an initial appears come be? maybe the realization that love never ever remains unstained ought to be celebrated, and also all hope because that true love abandoned.

And yet, Stevens ends v the gentle echoing that the song’s title, “All the me wants every one of you…” in spite of the harsh realities the the world and the brokenness that those we love, over there is no acquiring over the truth that our souls long to know and be completely known by others. Manelich’s love beats through this same desire, and he finishes action III through slaying Sebastian, the wolf who has been preying on Marta, and absconding with his bride come the mountains.

Marta is a woman who has actually been taught by years of cold and harsh abuse the love does not exist. To her, love is a thin veneer offered to cover over selfish motives and wicked abuses. Manelich’s willingness to pursue Marta in her brokenness is her first experience of really love. In fact, she suspect Manelich has actually some surprise motive. It seems difficult that anyone would love her in spite of her brokenness. She eventually realizes that what seemed impossible is a reality: Manelich wants all of her and also wants come be every hers.

See more: Justin Bieber Hairstyles Games, Justin Bieber Real Haircuts

Stevens’s struggle is Manelich’s struggle, and also Manelich’s struggle is our struggle. It is the resulting age of love. Whether between lovers, a brother and also a sister, or a son and his mother, love between two individuals requires the soft echo, “All that me wants every one of you.” even when “the landscape readjusted my point of view” and “now all of me thinks much less of you,” the echo need to still remain: “All the me wants every one of you…” What Sufjan and Carrie required was no perfect love or idealistic love, however a love in the middle of brokenness—a love that is no willing to walk away also when we see each rather sin and scars.

The love that throbs in Stevens’s spirit as “All that Me Wants every one of You” comes to a quiet end up can only come indigenous one source: “We love due to the fact that He an initial loved us” (1 man 4:19). Love is just able come triumph with brokenness if we are very first loved by God. In many ways, Manelich the basic shepherd is a picture of Jesus. The came under from the hill to it is in heart-broken, and also though his bride continued to be distant and also unwilling to believe that unconditional love might actually exist, he slew the worldly wolf who ruined her every night. In the zero of his love, the Church’s expect is rekindled. In a people where every of us is a crestfallen Manelich or one ashamed Marta, Christ’s overcome demonstrates what it method to say, “All the me wants every one of you…”