ns hope this question isn"t as well tirivial, however in The Punisher Harry Heck states to Frank

You room one dumb boy of a bitch. Bringing a knife come a gunfight.

You are watching: Never bring a knife to a gunfight

right before Frank death him making said knife shoot out from the shaft.

I always understood this quote as a reference to The Untouchables, once Malone (having a gun in hand) states to some thug trying come stab him

Isn"t that similar to a wop? bring a knife to a gun fight.

Just prior to running into a trap and also being gunned down.

So an initial of every is over there any source that this is without doubt intended as a recommendation to The Untouchables or is it just me drawing a connection where over there is no one (though the quotes are yes, really similar).

And furthermore, is the quote native The Untouchables maybe subsequently a recommendation to an additional (maybe much more famous) enlarge movie/story (to i m sorry The Punisher maybe actually refers, too)?


dialogue the-untouchables beginning the-punisher
re-publishing
boost this inquiry
monitor
request Jun 8 "12 in ~ 22:10
*

Napoleon Wilson♦Napoleon Wilson
57.6k5757 yellow badges318318 silver badges627627 bronze badges
4
Actually, it precedes The Untouchables -- it's in Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid.
–user28162
Nov 26 "15 at 9:39
that might first have memorably been said in 1987, to buy Spielberg's 'Raiders that the shed Ark' plot it out in 1981.
–user28814
Dec 17 "15 in ~ 12:10
include a comment |

2 answer 2


energetic earliest Votes
26
As much as I deserve to tell, it originates from The Untouchables film.

Films

According to searches in ~ Subzin, The Untouchables to be the first with this line, however has to be emulated in at the very least 20 various other films because 2000.

The Untouchables (1987)01:21:23 brings a knife to a gunfight.

The Target shoot First (2000)00:17:38 What room you doing, Max? happen a knife come a gunfight?

Shottas (2002)00:18:22 what space you doing, max? pass a knife to a gunfight?

Duplex (2003)01:17:10 Who room ya, pass a knife come a gunfight?

The Punisher (2004)01:06:55 carry a knife to a gunfight.

Waist Deep (2006)00:33:12 Nigga, don"t carry a knife to a gunfight, my...

BloodRayne II: Deliverance (2007)00:28:09 Ain"t it prefer an Irishmanto bring a bottle to a gunfight.

Dod vid ankomst (2008)00:59:29 How usual of you, bringing a knife come a gun fight.

Indiana Jones and also the Kingdom the the crystal Skull (2008)Nice shot kid, but I think girlfriend just brought a knife. Come a gunfight.

The Boondock Saints II: all Saints Day (2009)00:35:47 That"s like bringing a knife to a gunfight. / Yeah, or like bringing a really little gun come a gunfight.

The an excellent Guy (2009)00:37:24 never take a knife to a gunfight, mate.

Wonderful World (2009)00:26:00 Never carry a knife to a gunfight.

Death Hunter (2010)00:50:49 as with a rookie to carry a knife come a gun fight.

Including some variations ~ above the theme:

The Glimmer Man (1996)00:16:59 It"s type of like takin" a driver to a gunfight.

Black Cat Run (1998)00:32:40 A crow bar come a gun fight? autumn the fucking crowbar.

Urban Justice (2007)01:27:07 l understand you ain"t dumb sufficient to bring a fist come a gunfight.

G-Force (2009)01:12:27 just like humans. Bringing weapons to a an are junk fight.

Unrivaled (2010)00:28:46 you brought a knife come a bottle fight.

Cross (2011)00:08:06 Genius. Bring sticks to a gunfight.

Books

The Untouchables movie is based upon the 1957 publication of the exact same name, however it doesn"t seem like the quote originates from the book.

The first use that the phrase I might find in Google publications is in 1989, after the film come out: in a fishing magazine and a publication called Texas Wit and Wisdom). It does sound like it can be a Texas phrase.

This Ngram shows nothing prior to 1987:

*

Newspapers

Likewise, the an initial use I found in Google News is indigenous June 24, 1987 in the Argus Press"s review of The Untouchables.

See more: Knights Of The Old Republic Windowed Mode, How Can I Run This In A Windowed Mode

"Untouchables:" It"s a brilliant Movie Destined To it is in a Classic

...

He has actually lots of great lines as Ness"s mentor yet the finest one is as soon as he speak Ness appropriate away the first rule that police work: